That’s the Way the Animal Cracker Crumbles


It starts with the intention to make molded clay animal cracker pins to raise money for Cabrillo College’s Ceramics program and ends with….ceramic animal cracker pins that do just that.

But the journey is the interesting part. Not the noun what, but the verb how.

Let’s enjoy the fascinating loop-de-loops, curious sidetracks and obtuse angles to get there, learning a thousand things that don’t work on the way.

At first,  testing to find the best approach:Which clay?  Body stain or not? Oxide washes? Underglazes? Glaze? Testing, testing, testing. Always comparing the results to a real sample, which is surprisingly ORANGE toned. Important, too, are the molding methods and whether or not to add any clear glaze. (In this case, no, unless you want frosted animal crackers!) What you see above are the first efforts, which admit a bunch of possibilities, most of which prove unsuitable. Next slide, please!


After a few more trial runs and notes, the Final Four Finishes (ignoring the clear glaze on some of them) sit alongside a real cookie and ask for comparison. The crowd-sourcing group preferred #4 without the glaze, and so did I,  so that finish was the emphasis in the next round:

The Final Four Finishes Favorite with an added toasty edging. Could anyone guess the real ones from a random grouping of clay? In this shot the real ones are turned over, but most could not distinguish among the lot beforehand. The closest guesser noticed the excess material at the mold’s edge, not the applied colors. The job ahead was clear: make neat moldings and color them well.


And that’s what I did. Nearly four hundred crackers, pressed and molded neatly. Over twenty of each kind!



And bisque fired in several tumble-stacked  layers.




Most of the animal cracker shapes were clear: Lion, Giraffe, Gorilla, Koala. But there was one Mystery Animal. That’s the cracker at the bottom of this photo. Was it a pig? A big dog? A lactating mammal with gills? It provoked a lot of feedback and speculation to my Facebook query. But the definitive list of official Nabisco Animal Crackers appeared from a Friend, identifying it as….. a hyena. Really? Ah so. We also learned that the older molds from older crackers were larger and more detailed than the fresh-out-of-the-box-this-week cracker molds. Ah, profitability.



The task at hand: to color and glaze fire the collection. The sheer volume is daunting. Time to put tailbone on the stool and just get it done.

And the first fired round turned out too dark and blotchy! At least with low-fire clay and underglazes, an artist can just re-apply the lighter color treatment and refire. A burnt cookie is a burnt cookie, but a burnt clay cookie mostly just needs color adjusting and refiring.  That’s what you see in the shot above, lightening each one to send back into the kiln once again.


With a successful RE-firing, it’s time to glue on the pin-backs.  Long live E6000, or at least its smell.


A few fully formed, fired, re-fired and fitted animal cracker pins for fabulous fund-raising.

–Liz Crain, who thinks a curiously tenacious work ethic, a few laughs, and raising funds for Cabrillo College’s Ceramics Program are definitely worth the kink in her neck from hours in the same intent position.

Share this:

13 thoughts on “That’s the Way the Animal Cracker Crumbles

  1. […] Liz Crain: That’s the Way the Animal Cracker Crumbles. […]

  2. Hi, Liz ~
    I enjoyed the documentation and story of the animal crackers. As I was watching the process, I was reminded of a video I saw recently of Ai Weiwei and many sunflower seeds. I thought if you hadn’t seen it, that you may be interested:

  3. I meant to say glaze testing – not glazing.

  4. WOW Liz! That’s a lot of cookies and testing! I do a bunch of glazing, but I’ve never made that many of anything – I’m in awe! Glad they were a big hit and were able to raise money for a good cause. Curiosity question – did you use the real cookies to make your molds?

    1. Hi Bonnie!
      Thanks for coming by!
      Yes, I used the real cookies for the molds, BUT!!!! I had some older molds as well and let me just say that the cookies in the past were larger and held more details than the cookies of the present….only noticeable side by side, but then undeniable.

  5. wonderful! I found this entertaining, educational and interesting!
    good luck on the fund raising, I bet they sell like… hotcakes!

    1. HI Glynnis, thanks for dropping by here.
      The pins DID sell well in Davis and we have about 3-4 other opportunities before the end of the semester. That is gratifying.
      SO glad you found the saga interesting …at times I wondered just what I thought I was getting into!
      All good now though.

  6. What a great idea! And so well executed. Thanks for sharing. I’m so horrible at taking the time to document my work process, but I can see how valuable it is. You are an inspiration!

    1. Hi Patricia,
      I think of the photos as storytelling, and then I just add some word detail. There are always interesting snags and problems to solve in ceramic work, as you well know! I would love to read and see what shop talk you would share…
      And I missed you at the Eight from ACGA reception!!!!

  7. Animal cookie pins?! Love them!!! Can we buy them, too?

    1. Lois, yes you can buy some. Don’t know what’s left after the weekend, but I imagine your choice is still wide open. They were going for an incredible donation asking price of $3 each, the hope being to raise $1000. For you, we would need to factor in some postage, but tell me what you’re thinking!

  8. Thank you for taking us on this cookie copying caravan with you. It was great fun to participate as part of the crowd source.

    1. Hi Neno,
      Your observations were vital! Thanks so much.

Comments are closed.